The New Zealand Veterinary Association (NZVA) explicitly states it does not support electronic collars (e-collars/shock collars) that deliver aversive stimuli. They cite risks of pain, stress, and negative welfare outcomes, and recommend positive reinforcement training (or trainers skilled in it) instead. They note that for predatory aggression (e.g., chasing sheep/rabbits), there exists an “effective humane alternative,” so e-collars are not supported—even if euthanasia is the other option.
** I cannot support a policy position or organization that would endorse this tradeoff. My opinion is it is inhumane.
[Note “predatory aggression” is a layman’s term. Read “On Aggression” by Lorenz. I expect better from professional organizations. Further “risk” isn’t the same as a known outcome and is on a spectrum.]
Sam Basso, known as Sam The Dog Trainer, is a professional dog trainer and behaviorist serving Phoenix, Scottsdale, Mesa, Tempe, Chandler, Glendale, Gilbert, Paradise Valley, and surrounding areas. Some posts use AI-assisted drafting for clarity. This blog participates in affiliate programs (including Amazon Associates). Purchases via links may earn me a small commission at no extra cost to you.
No comments:
Post a Comment